THE OUTSIDER AND BILLIE LURK: A COMPLEX FINAL CHAPTER


I. UNIQUE RELATIONSHIP: NEITHER MARKED NOR MUNDANE

[From Death of the Outsider gameplay & cutscenes]:

  • Unusual Connection: Unlike other protagonists, Billie Lurk's relationship with The Outsider is neither that of a Marked bearer nor an ordinary person:

    • She never receives his formal Mark
    • Yet gains Void powers through alternative means
    • He appears to her without the typical ritual requirements
    • Their connection exists outside his usual patterns

  • Initial Encounters: The Outsider first appears to Billie after her reunion with Daud:

    • "I'm here because you are different. The Void has found you through the cracks in a broken world."
    • Acknowledges her unique temporal state: "Part of you is from a world that no longer exists."
    • Shows interest in her "fractured" nature due to timeline alterations

[From Void artifacts in Death of the Outsider]:

  • Instead of the Mark, Billie receives Void artifacts that grant powers:
    • The Eye: Allows her to see through dimensions, targeting Void energy
    • The Arm: Provides displace ability (similar to Blink but with different mechanics)
    • These physical manifestations represent a different type of bond with the Void

II. ANTAGONISTIC MISSION: HIRED KILLER

[From Death of the Outsider main plot]:

  • Central Conflict: Unlike other protagonists who use Outsider-given powers to pursue personal goals, Billie's explicit mission is to eliminate The Outsider himself:

    • Recruited by Daud for "one last job"
    • Told The Outsider must die to end his influence on the world
    • Initially accepts this perspective without question

  • The Outsider's Response: Surprisingly, he appears neither angry nor resistant:

    • "So that old killer wants one final mission."
    • "When you find me... what will you do, I wonder?"
    • Exhibits curiosity rather than self-preservation

[From Billie's journal entries]:

  • Billie's initial attitude is professional detachment:
    • "Just another target. The most important one, but still just a job."
    • Shows skepticism about Daud's certainty
    • Notes the irony of using Void powers to eliminate their source

III. VISIONS OF THE PAST: REVEALING THE OUTSIDER'S HUMANITY

[From vision sequences in Death of the Outsider]:

  • Fragmenting Memories: Throughout her journey, Billie experiences visions of The Outsider's human past:

    • Sees his abduction as a frightened boy
    • Witnesses his ritual sacrifice
    • Feels his terror as the knife cuts his throat
    • Experiences the moment of his transformation

  • Empathic Connection: These visions create unusual emotional resonance:

    • Billie notes: "I felt his fear. Not a god. A boy."
    • The visions occur without The Outsider deliberately causing them
    • Suggests the Void itself is revealing his past to her

[From The Outsider's comments on these visions]:

  • When confronted, he acknowledges this shared understanding:
    • "You've seen what they did to me. What they made me become."
    • "You understand what it means to be unmade by others' hands."
    • Creates a parallel between their experiences of being transformed against their will

IV. PARALLEL HISTORIES: UNEXPECTED SIMILARITIES

[From character background comparison]:

  • Shared Experiences: Billie and The Outsider have striking biographical parallels:

    • Both were homeless street children
    • Both were exploited by powerful figures
    • Both underwent transformations that changed their fundamental nature
    • Both became observers of a world they were partly separated from

  • Outsider's Recognition: He explicitly acknowledges these connections:

    • "We're not so different, are we? Taken from the streets, shaped by others' hands."
    • "You've been given many names, just as I was. Billie Lurk. Meagan Foster. The orphan girl who watched her mother die."

[From Billie's reflections]:

  • She gradually recognizes these similarities:
    • "We were both used. Made into other people's tools."
    • Questions if killing him would make her like the cultists who sacrificed him
    • Begins to see their connection as meaningful rather than coincidental

V. THE VOID'S SELECTION: CHOSEN WITHOUT THE MARK

[From Death of the Outsider lore & dialogue]:

  • Alternative Path: The Outsider explains Billie's unique connection:

    • "The Mark is just one way the Void touches someone."
    • "You've been chosen, but not by me. By the Void itself."
    • "Your broken state – existing across possible timelines – created natural fissures for Void energy."

  • Mechanical Distinctiveness: Billie's powers differ from other protagonists:

    • Displace: Creates a shadow-self to teleport to (rather than instant Blink)
    • Foresight: More limited than Dark Vision but allows marking multiple targets
    • Semblance: Face-stealing ability unique to her character
    • These differences reflect her indirect connection to Void power

[From environmental storytelling & collectibles]:

  • Various texts suggest the Void sometimes chooses people directly:
    • Ancient scrolls mention "those touched without the Black-Eyed God's attention"
    • References to "natural conduits" who develop powers without formal Marking
    • Suggests Billie represents a rare but documented phenomenon

VI. QUESTIONS OF CHOICE: THE ETHICAL DILEMMA

[From late-game conversations]:

  • Philosophical Debate: As Billie learns more, The Outsider poses ethical questions:

    • "Will you kill me because you're told to, or will you make your own choice?"
    • "I never asked for this existence. Does that matter to you?"
    • "How different are you from those who held the knife to my throat?"

  • Unsolicited Insights: He offers perspectives that complicate her mission:

    • "Daud blames me for his choices, but I never directed his hand."
    • "If I die, do you think the Void simply disappears? Or will something else emerge in my place?"
    • "We both know how a mob can justify a murder to themselves."

[From Billie's increasing doubt]:

  • Her notes reflect growing moral uncertainty:
    • "What happens to the Void without him? Something worse?"
    • "Maybe he deserves hatred, but does he deserve death?"
    • "Daud wants revenge. But against what? A god? A victim? Both?"

VII. FINAL DECISION: MERCY OR JUDGMENT

[From Death of the Outsider ending sequences]:

  • The Ultimate Choice: The game culminates in Billie's decision:

    • Kill The Outsider: Complete Daud's mission, ending his cosmic influence
    • Free The Outsider: Return him to humanity by speaking his true name

  • The Outsider's Acceptance: Regardless of choice, he shows understanding:

    • If killed: "You have done something impossible."
    • If freed: "These eyes were closed for centuries and I saw everything... and now I'm free."

[From ending narration based on choice]:

  • Killing Path: "The Outsider is no more. The Void lost its black-eyed avatar."
  • Freeing Path: "Perhaps he walks the world now, tasting those pleasures he was denied for millennia."
  • Both endings acknowledge the cosmic significance of Billie's choice while suggesting the Void itself continues to exist

VIII. TRANSFORMATION OF ANTAGONISM: FROM TARGET TO PERSON

[From dialogue progression analysis]:

  • Evolution of Address: The Outsider's way of speaking to Billie changes:

    • Early game: Formal, distant, using her full name
    • Mid-game: More conversational, acknowledging shared understanding
    • Late game: Almost intimate, using her childhood experiences in their discussions

  • Billie's Changing Perspective: Her internal monologues shift:

    • Initially refers to him as "it" or "the black-eyed bastard"
    • Gradually begins using "him" and "the Outsider"
    • By the end, considers his humanity and right to choice

[From visual storytelling elements]:

  • Their physical positioning in scenes evolves:
    • First encounters: He appears at a distance, above her
    • Later encounters: They appear at the same level, face to face
    • Final encounter: He is below her, physically vulnerable

IX. DAUD'S SHADOW: THE TRIANGULAR RELATIONSHIP

[From Death of the Outsider narrative structure]:

  • Three-Way Dynamic: Daud creates a complex triangle:

    • Daud hates The Outsider for enabling his life as an assassin
    • Billie feels loyalty to Daud but increasingly questions his mission
    • The Outsider views Daud with a mixture of disappointment and respect

  • The Outsider's Commentary on Daud:

    • "We let you live, Daud, when you deserved to die."
    • "For all his bitterness, Daud was one of my favorites."
    • These comments reveal a complex relationship that Billie witnesses

[From Billie's observations]:

  • She increasingly notes the parallels:
    • "Daud was shaped by the Outsider. I was shaped by Daud."
    • "Both of them playing games with people's lives."
    • Questions whether killing The Outsider would truly free Daud from his guilt

X. LEGACY AND IMPACT: BILLIE'S ULTIMATE AGENCY

[From concluding narrative elements]:

  • Breaking the Cycle: Regardless of player choice, Billie's actions represent a definitive end:

    • The age of the Outsider concludes
    • The cycle of Marked individuals ends
    • The Void continues but without its human avatar
    • She becomes the only person to ever truly affect The Outsider's existence

  • Final Narration Significance: The post-decision narration emphasizes:

    • "The world will change in ways none of us can know"
    • Billie disappears, her ultimate fate unknown
    • The cosmos continues with a fundamental alteration to its structure

[From thematic resolution]:

  • Narrative Symmetry: Their relationship ends with a reversal:
    • The Outsider began as a victim who became a powerful observer
    • He ends either freed from observation or permanently ended
    • Billie begins following another's mission but ends making her own choice
    • She ultimately holds power over the being who influenced so many others

The relationship between The Outsider and Billie Lurk represents the most complex and nuanced connection in the entire Dishonored series. Unlike the clearer dynamics with other characters, their relationship evolves from antagonism to understanding, from hunter and prey to two beings with shared experiences of transformation and loss.

Through Billie, the series ultimately humanizes The Outsider completely, revealing the victim behind the god and challenging the player to consider whether cosmic power justifies either worship or destruction. Their connection serves as the perfect conclusion to the Dishonored series' exploration of power, choice, and the complex morality of intervention versus observation.

Unlike other protagonists who receive power from The Outsider to change the world, Billie receives power to change The Outsider himself—completing the series' examination of how power functions at every level from the personal to the cosmic.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Outsider and Paintings in the Dishonored Series

The Outsider: Nature and Connection to Art The Outsider is a powerful entity bound to the Void, a supernatural dimension with a distinctly abstract, painterly aesthetic. While he doesn't create paintings himself, his presence and the Void's influence manifest visually in several key ways: Outsider Shrines are physical locations where the barrier between the Void and the physical world thins. These shrines are distinctively marked by disturbing paintings, abstract sculptures, and symbolic imagery (often featuring whales, geometric patterns, and dark materials). These artistic elements serve as visual indicators of the Void's presence and points where the Outsider can communicate directly. The Void itself possesses a surreal, non-Euclidean aesthetic that evokes a living, shifting painting. When characters enter this space, they experience a reality that feels like moving through an abstract, constantly transforming artwork where physical laws are malleable and landscape...
Read more

THE OUTSIDER AND THE RAT PLAGUE: CATALYST, OBSERVER, OR CAUSE?

I. THE PLAGUE'S ORIGIN: NATURAL VS. SUPERNATURAL [From in-game lore & audio logs] : Official Narrative : According to imperial records: The Rat Plague (aka "The Dunwall Plague") was a natural disease Originated from the Pandyssian Continent Carried by rats that stowed away on whaling ships Spread rapidly through Dunwall's poor districts before affecting the entire city Hidden Truth : Lord Regent Hiram Burrows' private audio log reveals: He deliberately imported plague rats from Pandyssia Intended as population control for poor districts Plan went catastrophically out of control Became an unintentional pandemic [From The Outsider's commentary] : Never claims direct responsibility for the plague States to Corvo: "The Lord Regent's hold on Dunwall is slipping. The plague has spiraled out of control." Notes the irony: "He imported the rats to clean out the poor districts. The plan worked – perhaps ...
Read more

THE OUTSIDER AND THE ELITE: POWER, WEALTH, AND VOID CONNECTIONS

I. THE ARISTOCRACY: INDIFFERENCE AND FASCINATION [From The Outsider's dialogue regarding aristocrats] : General Stance : When observing Dunwall's elite, The Outsider often displays: Detached amusement at their pretensions Particular interest when their privileged positions are threatened Recognition of how their wealth isolates them from consequences Little respect for wealth and status compared to interesting choices Direct Commentaries : On the Boyle Family: "The Boyles have deep pockets and deeper misgivings about the Lord Regent." On aristocrats during plague: "Such privilege – these people never have to face the consequences of their actions." On Karnaca's elite: "Money insulates them from the realities of the Duke's rule." [From The Heart's revelations about aristocrats] : When pointed at wealthy characters, The Heart often reveals: Hidden cruelties beneath polished exteriors Corruption, betrayal, and moral compromise Emp...
Read more