THE OUTSIDER AND ANTON SOKOLOV: A STUDY IN OBSESSION AND REJECTION


I. SOKOLOV'S PURSUIT: THE UNREQUITED SEEKER

[From in-game dialogue & Heart revelations]:

  • Lifelong Obsession: Anton Sokolov, Royal Physician and Head of the Academy of Natural Philosophy, devoted significant portions of his life attempting to contact The Outsider:

    • "For all his brilliance, Sokolov is a fool to seek the Outsider with rites and spells." (The Heart)
    • "I once met a man who solved the riddle of The Void, though he did not know it. His name was Sokolov." (Granny Rags)

  • Methodical Approach: Unlike cultists seeking worship, Sokolov pursued The Outsider with scientific determination:

    • Collected and studied bone charms and runes
    • Analyzed the mathematical patterns in Void artifacts
    • Conducted experiments on whale oil properties
    • Created detailed anatomical studies of whales, suspecting their connection to The Void

[From Sokolov's laboratory notes & sketches]:

  • Rituals Attempted: Sokolov tried numerous methods to summon The Outsider:
    • Blood rituals with "questionable ingredients" (implied human sacrifice)
    • Complex mathematical formulas carved into ritual spaces
    • Alchemical experiments combining whale oil with various rare substances
    • Occult symbols arranged in specific patterns during astronomical alignments

II. THE OUTSIDER'S DELIBERATE REJECTION

[From The Outsider's dialogue]:

  • Explicit Refusal: The Outsider speaks directly about Sokolov to Corvo:

    • "Anton Sokolov has made a great study of my runes, but he's not special like you are. He wasn't chosen and doesn't bear my Mark, so he can't unlock their secrets."
    • "Sokolov sees only the anatomy beneath the skin. He'll never know my true name."

  • Stated Reasons: The Outsider explains his disinterest in Sokolov:

    • "I don't appear to everyone who seeks me. Sokolov lacks any true curiosity. He seeks my audience to gain advantage over his rivals."
    • "His seductions and temptations are aimed at the wrong person."

[From Death of the Outsider content]:

  • Deeper Context: The Outsider's rejection of Sokolov reflects his own trauma:
    • As a victim of ritualistic sacrifice himself, The Outsider appears repulsed by Sokolov's "disgusting rituals" attempting to summon him
    • The Outsider values genuine interest over transactional approaches to power

III. SOKOLOV'S TECHNOLOGIES: VOID UNDERSTANDING WITHOUT CONNECTION

[From gameplay mechanics & lore]:

  • Whale Oil Technology: Despite The Outsider's rejection, Sokolov successfully harnessed Void energy through technology:

    • Refined whale oil processing for industrial power
    • Created "spiritual remedies" with healing properties
    • Developed the Arc Pylon and Wall of Light security technologies
    • Designed Tallboys and other military equipment

  • Incomplete Understanding: Sokolov achieved technological advancement without spiritual insight:

    • His technologies work but cause environmental devastation
    • His remedies heal but have severe side effects
    • His security devices function but are inhumane

[From environmental storytelling]:

  • Sokolov's apartment and laboratory contain numerous failed attempts to depict The Outsider:
    • Paintings showing only shadowy approximations
    • Sculptures with distorted features
    • Diagrams attempting to map The Void
    • These artistic failures symbolize his incomplete understanding

IV. PHILOSOPHICAL CONTRAST: SEEKING VS. CHOSEN

[From comparative character analysis]:

  • The Irony of Selection: The game creates a deliberate irony:

    • Those who desperately seek The Outsider's attention (Sokolov) never receive it
    • Those who never sought him (Corvo, Emily) are chosen and Marked
    • This reflects The Outsider's statement: "I appear to those who interest me"

  • Approaches to Knowledge:

    • Sokolov represents empirical, methodical study - dissection, experimentation, measurement
    • The Outsider values intuitive understanding, emotional resonance, and moral complexity
    • These approaches are portrayed as fundamentally incompatible

[From The Outsider's dialogue patterns]:

  • The Outsider consistently values:

    • Unpredictability and change ("Let's see what Corvo does now...")
    • Moral complexity ("Will you be the monster they claim?")
    • Personal growth ("You're not the same man who left Coldridge Prison")

  • Sokolov's approach lacks these qualities:

    • Seeks predictable, reproducible results
    • Views morality as irrelevant to scientific progress
    • Remains relatively unchanged in his worldview

V. ARTISTIC OBSESSION: SOKOLOV'S PAINTINGS OF THE OUTSIDER

[From collectible paintings & art descriptions]:

  • Failed Portraits: Throughout Dunwall, Sokolov's attempts to paint The Outsider can be found:

    • "The Outsider in Ceremonial Garb" - shows only a vague shadow
    • "The Outsider in Gristol Forest" - depicts a figure with incorrect features
    • "The Outsider and the Circumscribed Void" - abstract representation failing to capture his essence

  • Artistic Frustration: Sokolov's notes reveal increasing desperation:

    • "I have seen him in dreams, yet cannot capture his likeness upon waking."
    • "The black eyes I can paint, but the essence eludes me still."
    • "Perhaps no mortal hand can truly depict what exists beyond mortality."

[From dialogue with other characters]:

  • The Boyle sisters discuss Sokolov's obsession:
    • "He's been painting that same subject for years."
    • "He claims it's the same figure, though the paintings look nothing alike."
    • "He's convinced if he captures the likeness perfectly, the subject will appear to him."

VI. EVOLUTION ACROSS GAMES: CHANGING DYNAMICS

[From Dishonored 2]:

  • Sokolov's Changing Perspective: By the events of Dishonored 2, Sokolov has aged and his approach has changed:

    • Less focused on capturing The Outsider
    • More concerned with practical applications of his knowledge
    • Shows regret for some of his earlier, more ruthless experiments

  • The Outsider's Commentary: When Sokolov appears in Dishonored 2, The Outsider remarks:

    • "Anton Sokolov made a name for himself in weapons, anatomy, and liquor. Not so much in the field of proper locksmithing."
    • This more humorous, less scornful tone suggests a slightly softened view

[From Death of the Outsider]:

  • By the time of the final game, Sokolov is portrayed as:
    • Having largely abandoned his pursuit of The Outsider
    • Focused on more humanitarian applications of technology
    • Perhaps achieving a degree of wisdom The Outsider might actually respect

VII. COMPETITION WITH PIERO: TWO PATHS TO UNDERSTANDING

[From comparative storytelling]:

  • The Contrasting Approaches:

    • Sokolov actively pursues The Outsider but is rejected
    • Piero Joplin never deliberately seeks The Outsider but receives dream inspiration
    • This creates a narrative of two paths to knowledge:
      • Forced, demanding pursuit (unsuccessful)
      • Receptive, passive openness (successful)

  • The Outsider's Role: The Outsider deliberately sets the two scientists against each other:

    • Inspires Piero with designs that compete with Sokolov's
    • Creates a scientific rivalry that drives innovation
    • Demonstrates how he influences events indirectly

[From narrative resolution in low chaos ending]:

  • Ultimately, the cure for the rat plague requires both men's knowledge:
    • Sokolov's empirical approach to biology
    • Piero's Void-inspired insights
    • Suggesting complete understanding requires both methodologies

VIII. SYMBOLIC REPRESENTATION: THE ARTIST VS. THE SUBJECT

[From thematic analysis]:

  • Sokolov as Colonizer: His approach to The Outsider mirrors colonial attitudes:

    • Attempts to capture, define, and control what he doesn't understand
    • Views The Outsider as a resource to be exploited for knowledge or power
    • Uses rituals appropriated from other cultures without understanding

  • The Outsider's Resistance: By refusing to appear to Sokolov, The Outsider represents:

    • Resistance to being defined by others
    • The failure of empirical methods to capture spiritual realities
    • The impossibility of fully understanding the cosmos through measurement alone

[From environmental storytelling & visual design]:

  • Sokolov's laboratory contrasted with Void spaces:
    • Laboratory: Rigid, ordered, geometric, tools of dissection and measurement
    • Void: Fluid, chaotic, organic, defying conventional physics
    • This visual contrast reinforces their philosophical incompatibility

IX. WHALE OIL INDUSTRY: INDIRECT CONNECTION TO THE OUTSIDER

[From world-building elements & ecological themes]:

  • Exploitation of Connection: While failing to contact The Outsider directly, Sokolov exploits the connection between whales and The Void:

    • Develops industrial processing of whale oil, the primary energy source
    • Creates technologies that harness Void energy through whale products
    • Unintentionally damages the delicate connection between worlds through whale hunting

  • The Outsider's Concern: Several comments suggest The Outsider's displeasure:

    • "The songs of the great whales are growing fewer."
    • "There's no great change coming to the world, not compared to the death of the oceans."
    • These suggest Sokolov's whale oil industry damages something The Outsider values

[From ecological consequences in the game world]:

  • The rat plague itself may be indirectly connected to the disruption of natural balance:
    • Whale populations decimated by Sokolov's industry
    • Void energies leaking into the world in uncontrolled ways
    • Natural predators (like rats) becoming vessels for Void corruption

X. LEGACY: INTELLECTUAL HUBRIS VS. COSMIC MYSTERY

[From complete narrative arc across all games]:

  • Sokolov's Ultimate Legacy:

    • Scientific advancement without wisdom
    • Power without understanding
    • Knowledge without insight

  • What The Outsider Reveals Through Rejection:

    • Some knowledge cannot be seized, only received
    • Understanding the Void requires humility
    • True insight comes from experience, not experimentation

[From final characterizations in Death of the Outsider]:

  • The elderly Sokolov ultimately gains a measure of wisdom:

    • Recognizes the human cost of his earlier work
    • Accepts the limitations of scientific understanding
    • Acknowledges mysteries beyond his comprehension

  • If The Outsider is freed rather than killed:

    • He becomes human again, potentially subject to scientific study
    • This creates a final irony - when Sokolov is too old to continue his pursuit, The Outsider becomes accessible
    • The ultimate "answer" comes only after Sokolov has stopped asking the question

The relationship between The Outsider and Anton Sokolov represents one of the most fascinating philosophical tensions in the Dishonored universe - the conflict between empirical knowledge and mystical understanding, between demanding pursuit and receptive openness. Through Sokolov's frustrated attempts to study, summon, and depict The Outsider, the games explore fundamental questions about how we approach the unknown and the limits of human understanding.

The Outsider's consistent rejection of Sokolov, despite the latter's brilliance and determination, serves as a reminder that some aspects of reality resist direct examination, that the cosmos contains mysteries that cannot be dissected or measured, only experienced. Yet Sokolov's technological achievements, despite his spiritual failures, demonstrate the value of scientific inquiry even when its ultimate goals remain elusive.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Outsider and Paintings in the Dishonored Series

The Outsider: Nature and Connection to Art The Outsider is a powerful entity bound to the Void, a supernatural dimension with a distinctly abstract, painterly aesthetic. While he doesn't create paintings himself, his presence and the Void's influence manifest visually in several key ways: Outsider Shrines are physical locations where the barrier between the Void and the physical world thins. These shrines are distinctively marked by disturbing paintings, abstract sculptures, and symbolic imagery (often featuring whales, geometric patterns, and dark materials). These artistic elements serve as visual indicators of the Void's presence and points where the Outsider can communicate directly. The Void itself possesses a surreal, non-Euclidean aesthetic that evokes a living, shifting painting. When characters enter this space, they experience a reality that feels like moving through an abstract, constantly transforming artwork where physical laws are malleable and landscape...
Read more

THE OUTSIDER AND THE RAT PLAGUE: CATALYST, OBSERVER, OR CAUSE?

I. THE PLAGUE'S ORIGIN: NATURAL VS. SUPERNATURAL [From in-game lore & audio logs] : Official Narrative : According to imperial records: The Rat Plague (aka "The Dunwall Plague") was a natural disease Originated from the Pandyssian Continent Carried by rats that stowed away on whaling ships Spread rapidly through Dunwall's poor districts before affecting the entire city Hidden Truth : Lord Regent Hiram Burrows' private audio log reveals: He deliberately imported plague rats from Pandyssia Intended as population control for poor districts Plan went catastrophically out of control Became an unintentional pandemic [From The Outsider's commentary] : Never claims direct responsibility for the plague States to Corvo: "The Lord Regent's hold on Dunwall is slipping. The plague has spiraled out of control." Notes the irony: "He imported the rats to clean out the poor districts. The plan worked – perhaps ...
Read more

THE OUTSIDER AND THE ELITE: POWER, WEALTH, AND VOID CONNECTIONS

I. THE ARISTOCRACY: INDIFFERENCE AND FASCINATION [From The Outsider's dialogue regarding aristocrats] : General Stance : When observing Dunwall's elite, The Outsider often displays: Detached amusement at their pretensions Particular interest when their privileged positions are threatened Recognition of how their wealth isolates them from consequences Little respect for wealth and status compared to interesting choices Direct Commentaries : On the Boyle Family: "The Boyles have deep pockets and deeper misgivings about the Lord Regent." On aristocrats during plague: "Such privilege – these people never have to face the consequences of their actions." On Karnaca's elite: "Money insulates them from the realities of the Duke's rule." [From The Heart's revelations about aristocrats] : When pointed at wealthy characters, The Heart often reveals: Hidden cruelties beneath polished exteriors Corruption, betrayal, and moral compromise Emp...
Read more